A Left Brain Approach to the Right Brain Holistic Health Paradigm
by Jae Sabol, CHEK IV, CHEK HLC II, NMT, NLP
Holistic health care, also known as complimentary alternative medicine (CAM), has
continued to grow at unprecedented levels as traditional Western dogma is challenged
by its own rising costs1, the association of side affects, and a burgeoning field
of alternative health care methods advocating prevention and treatment through organic
food, herbs and traditional Eastern approaches such as acupuncture, reflexology,
meditative practices and energy healing. Currently, in the U.S., CAM use has topped
40%2,3,4,5 with no sign of slowing down6. In one study CAM use has even surpassed such
time honored practices as the use of prayer (35%)7,8, for health related issues.
As someone who has worked in the holistic health field for over 12 years now, I have
come to notice a very interesting pattern. The most devout Western medicine practitioners
(Specialists, MDs and PhDs of medicine or pharmacology) tend to have a very left brain,
"it must be scientifically proven," approach to medicine and shy away from holistic
health practices9. Conversely, the most devout Eastern medicine practitioners (acupuncturists,
reflexologists, energy healers, homeopaths, kinesiologists, etc.) tend to see traditional
Western care and the pharmaceutical industry as more detrimental than beneficial to human
health and founded on symptom treatment rather than the etiology of health problems.
Interestingly enough, just as science has shown the many benefits provided by various
pharmaceuticals, surgeries, and Western approaches, so too has science progressed
enough to validate many CAM practices. So why does it seem neither group is willing
to embrace the benefits of the other?
In this article I hope to present a method of evaluation and assessment of health
concerns that will help the interested individual, the patient, and the health
practitioner alike in determining the most effective method for achieving and maintaining
optimum health. As many individuals are not willing to utilize one system or the
other due to previous teachings, social bias, or a lack of education on the benefits
of a system, it seems logical that adhering to the system the individual is comfortable
with while gently integrating some of the benefits of the unfamiliar system may be
the most effective and acceptable approach. This allows the health practitioner to
conform to the beliefs and desires of the individual while doubling the number of
modalities he or she may draw on for resolving any health concern.
Both holistic health care/CAM and traditional Western approaches cannot only coexist,
but with appropriate attention to patients' symptoms and the overall state of their
health a more affective and truly holistic approach integrating the best of both
systems can be implemented. The foundation of this approach is the concept of physiological
load10,11.
Physiological load is the sum total of all stressors on the body and is best evaluated
by dividing the body into 4 primary systems of systems: musculo-skeletal system
(physical structure), visceral system (internal organs), hormonal system, and limbic/emotional
system (psychology). These four systems are each essential to our survival and are
also intimately related in that they have the ability to reduce excessive stress
in any one area by distributing this load into any one or all of the other systems12,13,14,15,16,17.
This protective mechanism insures that no singular system becomes overloaded to
the point of total collapse of the whole.
Examples of this system of balancing at work are the Chinese acupuncture meridians
and the way they relate organs to muscles and vice versa18 or the affects of any powerful
emotional state on the hormonal system, most aspects of the visceral system (increased
heart rate, changes in digestion, etc.) and physiology (posture). The above mentioned affects of emotional states on the rest of the systems will also occur secondary to any traumatic event originating with the structure or organs; such as a car accident or a heart attack. The key in all these examples it the body's ability to dissipate stress and redistribute it throughout all the systems so that no one system is consumed or overloaded.
One way to think about physiological load is to envision each of the systems as a
sink and all of the sinks being connected by one piping system. A stressful event
affecting one or several systems would be like adding water to the appropriate sink
or sinks and the piping system would be the body's way of returning to the most
appropriate level of homeostasis for longevity of the whole system. Keeping this
analogy in mind, reduction of stress on any one system has the affect of indirectly
reducing stress on all other systems. One of the most obvious examples of this at
work would be the effectiveness of meditation or meditative type practices like yoga,
tai chi, and Qigong as a CAM for most all health maladies. These relaxing and stimulating
practices which impact the limbic/emotional system and then overflow benefits onto
all of the other systems have been shown to aid in everything from cancer19 to arthritis20.
A Western medicine example would be the effects of any medication that alleviates a
symptom and improves a person's quality of life, thus increasing their ability to be
active, or improving their psychology and thus having a concomitant affect on the
other three systems.
The usefulness of this way of looking at things, for the individual seeking optimum
health, the CAM practitioner, or the traditional Western doctor, is in determining
where the greatest level of physiological load is BEFORE choosing one's course of
action. Because the weakest link in any system will always be the system's downfall,
identification and correction of the weakest link should ALWAYS be undertaken along
with any medical or therapeutic approach. Consider that a person of great athletic
skill will accomplish little in their sport if their psychology is counter to their
physical prowess; or a person being treated in the traditional Western sense for
post menopausal symptoms will not last long if degenerative kidney or liver condition
is ignored. Conversely, a knee or back surgery patient with a properly functioning
digestive system21 and/or ideally aligned structural system will heal faster due to
increased nutritional support and reduced structural stressors respectively22. Correcting
or eliminating any overwhelming stress on any one of the four systems, be it with
Western medicine or the CAM approach will yield the most improvement to quality of life
and symptom resolution of minor stressors on any of the other systems.
This model is also beneficial as it allows the individual working with others or
looking to help one's self a way of looking at the big picture and developing strategies
that reduce load on ALL systems. Consider the enrichment, physiological and psychological
benefits of hobbies, quality time spent with family, or other activities that you find
not only fun, but truly stimulating! Think of those activities that transport you
away from all cares and worries and bring peace not only to the mind but to the body
as well. If you were to think back to when you were younger, when fun and relaxation
was not something you planned for but rather something you allowed, what did you do?
What brought you the most joy and happiness?
Whatever it was, do you still do it? Most will answer "no," but these activities,
that were once so common sense, so taken for granted, and so valuable, can yield
the same or greater benefits today that they provided you as a child. Think of the
four sinks and what effect rekindling a hobby or really taking time out for those
that mean the most to you would have on the amount of stress pouring in to each of
them. What effect would drinking more water, resolving long standing family feuds
and releasing the emotional burden, or cleaning up your digestion and improving the
quality of the food you eat have?
The answer is, it would have a HUGE effect so start now! The biggest lesson I have
learned from the physiological load model is to discount nothing, weigh the affects
of everything, and do all you can to drain those sinks so that those effects you can't
avoid can easily be distributed. Follow this approach for maximum vitality and longevity,
and if you have symptoms, start this approach; the results will be immediately noticed
and carry over to more areas of your health and vitality than you can imagine. May you
live in health and happiness.
Jae Sabol is an exercise therapist and holistic lifestyle coach specializing in the
integration of Eastern and Western medicine as the ideal approach to creating effective
dietary and stress reduction programs, rehabilitation programs (neck, back, shoulder,
and hip pain), and programs for general health and longevity.
1 Pagan JA, Pauly MV. Access to conventional medical care and the use of complementary and alternative medicine. Health Aff., January 1, 2005; 24(1): 255-262
2 Jordan ML, Delunas LR. Quality of life and patterns of nontraditional therapy use by patients with cancer. Oncol Nurs Forum 2001; 28: 1107-1113.
3 Bennett M, Lengacher C. Use of complementary therapies in a rural cancer population. Oncol Nurs Forum 1999; 26: 1287-1294.
4 Bernstein BJ, Grasso T. Prevalence of complementary and alternative medicine use in cancer patients. Oncology 2001; 15: 1267-1272.
5 Richardson MA, Sanders T, Palmer JL et al. Complementary/alternative medicine use in a comprehensive cancer center and the implications for oncology. J Clin Oncol 2000; 18: 2505-2514.
6 Eisenberg DM, Davis RB, Ettner SL, et al. Trends in alternative medicine use in the United States, 1990-1997. JAMA. 1998;280:1569-1575.
7 McCaffrey AM, Eisenberg DM et al. Prayer for health concerts.. Arch of Inernt Med. 2000; 18: 2505-2514.
8 Kessler RC, Davis RB, Foster DF, et al. Long-term trends in the use of complementary and alternative medical therapies in the United States. Ann Intern Med. 2001;135:262-268
9 Borkan J, Neher JO, et al. Referrals for alternative therapies, J Fam Pract. 1994 Dec; 39(6):545-50
10 Chek P, Corrective Holistic Exercise Kinesiology Internship Level III, 2002; Encinitas, CA
11 Chek P, Holistic Lifestyle Coaching Internship Level I &II, 2002; Encinitas, CA
12 Korr IM, The Collected Papers of Irvin M. Korr Vol II, 1997, American Academy of Osteopathy. Indianapolis, IN
13 Maciocia, Giovanni. Foundations of Chinese Medicine: A Comprehensive Text for Acupuncturists and Herbalist. 1997, Churchill Livingstone, New York, NY
14 Pert CB, Molecules of Emotion, 1997, Scribner. New York, NY; pp. 130-149
15 Chek P, Corrective Holistic Exercise Kinesiology Internship Level IV, 2005; Vista, CA
16 McIntyre RS, Konarski JZ, et al. Hormone replacement therapy and antidepressant prescription patterns: a reciprocal relationship, CMAJ. 2005, Jan 4; 172(1).
17 Greenberg MA, Wortman CB, et al. Emotional expression and physical health: Revisiting traumatic memories or fostering self-regulation, JPSP. 1996, Vol. 71, No. 3, 588-602
18 Thie, John & Matthew, Thouch for Health: A Practical Guide to Natural Health with Acupressure Touch, 2005, DeVorss & Company; Camarillo, CA
19 Chen K, Yeung R, Exploratory studies of qigong therapy for cancer in China, Integr Cancer Ther, 2002
20 Garfinkel MS, Schumacher HR, et al. Evaluation of a yoga based regimen for treatment of osteoarthritis of the hands, J of Rheumatol., 1994 Dec; 21(12): 2341-3
21 Chek P, Holistic Lifestyle Coaching Internship Level III, 2005; Vista, CA
22 Chek P, Corrective Holistic Exercise Kinesiology Internship Level I, 2001; Encinitas, CA
|